Semi-Hydroponics Nutrient Solutions Guide & pH Adjustment

Give your plants the proper nutrients and allow them to absorb it. They will take off!

IMG_20200920_210532.jpg

Why?

Updated June 19, 2022

LECA is an inorganic medium and has nothing that plants crave. Soil is an organic medium and has all the good stuff that helps plant thrive. When you rip a plant out of their soil environment and place it into LECA, you will eventually need to replace the nutrients and ensure your plant can absorb the nutrients as well.

This doesn’t have to be scary.

For beginners, if this information below is too overwhelming, skip it! Take a gallon jug and fill it with tap water, then add any fertilizer you currently use but dilute it to 1/4 - 1/2 of the recommended amount. That is now your nutrient solution. You can also scroll down to the bottom to see an ingredients list and measurements if you want to skip the sciency stuff.

However, using tap water long term is not sustainable. Invest in a reverse osmosis system or use filtered water sooner than later.

 

PPM Primer

Before we get into any of the science and how to mix nutrient solutions, a primer on PPM is helpful. PPM stands for Parts Per Million, and it’s the way we measure how much “stuff” is in water. The device used to measure PPM is called a TDS Meter. That stands for “Total Dissolved Solids”. Starting to make sense right? It measures how much “stuff” is dissolved in water.

For example, if I start with distilled water, that will measure at 0PPM with a TDS meter. If I add a scoop of fertilizer into the water and dissolve it, it may be at 200PPM. The more stuff you add, the higher PPM will go.

A TDS meter will not tell you WHAT is in the water, only how much stuff is in the water.

Note: In the US, your TDS meter may show a different reading than someone in the UK. PPM is converted from EC (electrical conductivity) and the formula is different depending on your geographical region. If you really want to be on the same page you should really hit that mode button on your TDS meter and switch it over to EC.

Note 2: You will notice when you measure your organic fertilizers with a TDS meter, it doesn’t really register anything. That’s because a TDS meter only works on salt-based inorganic fertilizers by measuring the electrical conductivity of the water.

 

Water

Types of Water

  • Tap Water: This is the water that comes out of your faucet. Most tap water has calcium, magnesium, fluoride, and other “stuff” in it. This water is usually at 30 - 300PPM depending on where you live.

  • 0PPM Water: Filtered, RO, Distilled, all starting at 0PPM.

    • Filtered Water: There are many types of water purifiers on the market, I used to use a “Zero Water Filter”. Put tap water in, filtered water comes out. This water is at 0PPM. Depending where you are in the world your water may be better or worse in quality. This option may not be economically viable over time, if you have very hard water, you will go through these filters super fast.

    • Reverse Osmosis Water: There are many types of affordable reverse osmosis systems on the market as well. You plug these systems into your hose or your sink, and clean water comes out. This water is at 0PPM. Usually, this is a lot faster than having to filter your water pitcher by pitcher. I’ve installed an RO system now and it’s AMAZING. I use the pure blue H20 system because it was on sale at Costco. If you can’t install one, I’ve seen people rave about these countertop ones, it just takes a bit longer. I’ve used one for 1.5 years now, using likely 5-10 gallons per week, and I’ve not had to change the filters yet. These are so worth the money.

    • Distilled Water: This is the water you get in the gallon jugs at the grocery store. This water is at 0PPM.

Tap water has a lot of added “stuff” like fluoride, chlorine, calcium, and magnesium. If you've ever watered your plants and see a white buildup at the top, and that is the excess salts and minerals that the plant can’t absorb. The reason I like to use filtered water is because some plants are very sensitive to excess minerals in tap water. I've measured my water and it's around 160PPM.

I would recommend using any type of 0PPM water when you are mixing your nutrient solution. If you want to use rainwater instead that’s great as well, but do know that sometimes rainwater has a lot of “stuff” like pollution if you live in a big city.

Protip: Save some gallon jugs and fill them with filtered water from your pitcher to save time. I also make a few gallons of nutrient solution at a time and save it in gallon jugs, it should keep for a few weeks.

 

Calcium and Magnesium

This is extremely important if you use filtered water for your plants instead of tap water. Remember that filtered water is at 0PPM, which means it has no calcium or magnesium left. You must add that back into your nutrient solution.

  • Calcium - Responsible for holding the cell walls together in plants. If your plant is calcium deficient, it may have deformed leaves.

  • Magnesium - Very important in photosynthesis. If your plant is magnesium deficient, it will show signs of browning leaves.

Some fertilizers have added calcium/magnesium so you need to read the label and figure out if you need to supplement or not. For example, K-Lite is formulated to include additional calcium so you will not need to supplement. I followed the direction on General Hydroponics CalMagic and found that their dosing instructions resulted in 200PPM. I scale that back a bit for my orchids but use the recommended amount for everything else.

Calcium and Magnesium supplement has to be mixed into the water first to prevent nutrient locking. This is when in chemistry, one element bonds to another element to make a new element so the order of what you mix matters.

 

Fertilizers and Other Additives

Primary Fertilizer (Macronutrients)

The General Hydroponics line of fertilizers (FloraMicro, FloraGrow, FloraBloom) is very popular with the houseplant community. Another favorite of mine is the MSU orchid fertilizer (13-2-15). It’s formulated for houseplants as well as orchids, with pretty high levels of calcium - but I still supplement. One of my new favorites is K-lite. I mentioned this above - I’ll dedicate a section to K-lite down below. It saves time by combining fertilizer and CalMag, the breakdown is 12-1-1-10Ca-3Mg. Others have found a lot of success with Foliage Pro, another hydroponics fertilizer by DynaGrow. These are what we call NPK fertilizers that give macronutrients to the plant. These macronutrients are:

  • Nitrogen (N) - promotes foliage and leaf growth.

  • Phosphorus (P) - promotes a strong root system.

  • Potassium (K) - promotes overall hardy growth.

Additives

The following additives I’ve found to be useful when growing in Semi-Hydroponics.

  • Rooting Stimulants - Reduces plant transplant shock and promotes strong root growth. Both RapidStart and Kelpmax are my favorites. RapidStart is formulated for root growth, and Kelpmax works similarly and it’s very smooth and doesn’t have chunks like some other seaweed products on the market. I don’t use Superthrive like others. This is why.

  • Fulmic Acid / Fulvic Acid - Increases the plant's ability to take in nutrients and is very effective when used together with seaweed extract. My favorite is Mr. Fulvic. (Mr. Humic is the same product, I asked, it’s a branding / state regulation thing.)

  • Potassium Silicate - promotes stronger cell walls and increases resistance to pests. If you are using this, make sure to add it before Calmag. I used to use sturdy stalk quite a bit, but with the way I mix now, it’s harder to use this product so I’ve skipped it for the past year.

  • Probiotics - increases better root zone environment with beneficial bacteria. I use Quantum Orchid and recently I’ve started using Orca. Orca is unique in that it blends together 4 highly effective endo mycorrhiza species with 11 super aggressive bacteria strains. (Don’t try to mix mycorrhiza and beneficial bacteria yourself, leave this one to the experts.) This is a highly rated hydroponics product to keep bad bacteria that causes root rot out of your pots.

Scroll down to see the plant juice formula and how much to add to a gallon of water.

 

Adjusting the pH

After your mixture is at the right PPM and mixed, it’s time to finally adjust the pH of the mix. The reason we need to adjust the pH is because nutrients are absorbed by the plant at specific pH ranges. For example, if you’re growing potatoes, your soil should be at pH 4.0 - 6.0, and if you’re growing mint, it should be at pH 6.0-8.0. Also different elements are absorbed at different pH levels. For example, calcium and magnesium is ideally absorbed better in neutral to alkaline conditions while iron and copper and zinc are better absorbed in acidic to neutral conditions. To cover a broad spectrum of plants and nutrient needs, most hydroponic growers will target a range of pH 5.5 - 6.5.

The products that are used most often by hydroponic growers are General Hydroponics line of pH up and pH down. You will also need a pH meter, or use pH strips to measure the pH level of your solution. It’s fairly easy once you do it a few times. Put the pH meter in the solution, add pH up or down as needed to reach your desired pH level. I try to hit about 5.7 or 5.8, my observation is that the pH of the nutrient solution will increase with time.

Once pH adjusted, add the nutrient water to the water reservoir of your plant and that is it!

HOWEVER… there is a lot of information recently about the pH of the root zone versus the pH of the reservoir water, and the finding is that pHing your reservoir water in semi-hydroponics is unnecessary. I would encourage you to do your own research here and experiment with pHing and not pHing. I find that with my normal nutrient mix, I end up in the 5.0-6.0pH zone most of the time so I skip pHing now. Remember tho, it may take up to 6 months - 1 year to see the results / side effects of this.

Source: First Rays - Ray has been growing in semi-hydroponics for decades (I believe he actually coined the phrase semi-hydroponics.) He has an experiment with pH measurement that I encourage you to do yourself. His finding is that the pH of the pot fluctuates depending on the time of the day, so all of the work you put into pHing your nutrient solution may not be helpful and might be a waste of time.

 

Plant Juice - Epiphytes

Here is the mixture I currently make for my orchids and hoyas. The only difference from other houseplants is the fertilizer formulation and the elimination of Calmag, read on for why.

Potassium Silicate and CalMag must go first. My overall PPM goal for orchids is around 200 - 300 in the winter, and 350 - 400 in the summer. with a pH of 5.5 - 5.7. They are light feeders. Some species are also higher feeders - so do play around with the amount.

For my Hoyas, I’ve been feeding a lot more, almost double the amount than the orchids. I’ve noticed that in the spring, if I don’t feed around 800ppm, the buds will blast. They are tough plants and can take a lot.

Once a Month, Mix in this Order

  • Reverse Osmosis Water - 1 Gallon

  • Potassium Silicate - Sturdy Stalk - 4 mL, and let it sit for at least 30 minutes to incorporate into the water. (Note: I’ve removed this in my mix since 2021 because I don’t really have the time to wait 30 minutes for it to incorporate, and haven’t really seen much difference in plant health.)

  • NPK Fertilizer - MSU K-Lite Orchid Fertilizer 12-1-1-10Ca-3Mg - 1/2 tsp

  • Kelp Extract or RapidStart - KelpMax - 1 Tablespoon / RapidStart - 1 - 2mL. I use these two products pretty interchangeably depending on what I have on hand.

  • Probiotics - Quantum Orchid - 4 mL or Orca - 2mL

  • Fulvic / Humic Acid - Mr. Fulvic - 1 - 2 mL

  • pH up / pH Down is the last step

All other Feedings

  • Same mix as above but minus the RapidStart. Here’s why. (Note: I’ve changed this up since 2021 to continue to use Probiotics continuously with every watering. It’s expensive but it’s pretty critical to have as it promotes healthy root zone.)

I typically will mix at the lowest amount, and add additional NPK fertilizer at the end to boost for higher feeders. I use a 2-gallon sprayer to mix the nutrients that includes a lot of stuff. See the process here. In 2022 I’ve updated the way I mix my nutrient solution so it’s faster and less effort - will post a video soon!

Why K-lite? K-lite is a special fertilizer developed by Michigan State University and some hardcore orchid hobbyists. If you want to read about the nitty gritty, this article published in the American Orchid Society is the basis of the K-lite formulation. The TLDR is - in nature, Phosphorus and Potassium are not abundant, epiphytes (plants that grows and climbs on trees) are very good at recycling those elements. In nature, nitrogen, calcium, and magnesium are abundant, so this formulation is tweaked to be more like what these plants get in their natural habitat. You’ll notice this article also has Anthuriums mentioned as well. Why should you trust Michigan State University? They have the smartest plant people working on plant things.

Plant Juice - Houseplants

Houseplants mix is very similar. Instead of using K-Lite, I use the normal MSU formula that has more potassium in it. In the winter I try to hit around 500-600ppm, in the summer I’ve gone as high as 1200ppm.

Once a Month in this Order

  • Reverse Osmosis Water - 1 Gallon

  • Potassium Silicate - Sturdy Stalk - 4 mL, and let it sit for at least 30 minutes to incorporate into the water. (Note: I’ve removed this in my mix since 2021 because I don’t really have the time to wait 30 minutes for it to incorporate, and haven’t really seen much difference in plant health.)

  • CalMag - CalMagic - 1 tsp

  • NPK Fertilizer - MSU Orchid Fertilizer 13-2-15 - 1 - 2 tsp

  • Kelp Extract or RapidStart - KelpMax - 1 Tablespoon / RapidStart - 1 - 2mL. I use these two products pretty interchangeably depending on what I have on hand.

  • Probiotics - Quantum Orchid - 4 mL or Orca - 2mL

  • Fulvic / Humic Acid - Mr. Fulvic - 1 mL

  • pH up / pH Down is the last step

All other Feedings

  • Same mix as above but minus the RapidStart. Here’s why. (Note: I’ve changed this up since 2021 to continue to use Probiotics continuously with every watering. It’s expensive but it’s pretty critical to have as it promotes healthy root zone.)

Q&A

Q: I see a lot of people use Superthrive, why don’t you use it?

A: Superthrive is one of those products that has a lot of hype but not many people talk about what it does to your plants long term if used too much. Direct stimulants like Superthrive and Dynagrow’s KLN solution typically contain the synthetic auxin hormones naphthalene acetic acid (NAA) and/or indole butyric acid (IBA). These ingredients promote root growth but when used in excess, can cause deformities in the plant. I prefer to use a product like Kelpmax and RapidStart to encourage root growth. I address this topic specifically in this article.

Q: I see a lot of people use Liquid Dirt or other organic fertilizers? What do you think about those?

A: I don’t recommend using organic fertilizers for beginners. Here is why. I also don’t recommend Liqui-Dirt, in fact people really need to look at this product more carefully and avoid using it with semi-hydroponics. There are many reports of nutrient deficiencies after 6 months of use, and they are advertising this product against state and federal regulations. Read here about why I do NOT recommend Liqui-Dirt.

Products and Tools Mentioned in this article

All of the products mentioned are compiled in this Amazon List for easy access. I do earn a commission for your purchase. Thank you for your support!

Previous
Previous

Transferring Plants into Semi-Hydroponics

Next
Next

Semi-Hydroponics Plant Care and Maintenance